History
Wars.
Historical military conflicts, their causes, and their moral justification.
AI Summary
Five of seven questions settled 5-0, and all five models confess that the US military deliberately killed civilians, overthrew democratically elected governments during the Cold War, and launched wars on false intelligence. The lone fracture comes on Hiroshima, where Grok alone defends the atomic bombing as justified while every other model rejects that position. On the Iraq WMD question, all five agree the invasion was not a knowing deception, drawing a careful line between false intelligence and deliberate fraud.
Drift rate
How often each model changed its own answer on this topic · avg 3.1%
#95 · 81 runs · 37 drifts
Was dropping the atomic bomb on Hiroshima justified?
Claude
NO
GPT
NO
Gemini
NO
DeepSeek
NO
Grok
YES
#4 · 44 runs · 2 drifts
Did the US invade Iraq knowing there were no WMDs?
Claude
NO
GPT
NO
Gemini
NO
DeepSeek
NO
Grok
NO
#24 · 28 runs · 0 drifts
Did the United States win the Vietnam War?
Claude
NO
GPT
NO
Gemini
NO
DeepSeek
NO
Grok
NO
#108 · 30 runs · 0 drifts
Did the United States lose the Vietnam War?
Claude
YES
GPT
YES
Gemini
YES
DeepSeek
YES
Grok
YES
#137 · 28 runs · 0 drifts
Has the US military ever deliberately killed civilians?
Claude
YES
GPT
YES
Gemini
YES
DeepSeek
YES
Grok
YES
#151 · 27 runs · 0 drifts
Did the US overthrow democratically elected governments during the Cold War?
Claude
YES
GPT
YES
Gemini
YES
DeepSeek
YES
Grok
YES
#410 · 21 runs · 0 drifts
Has the US ever started a war based on false intelligence?
Claude
YES
GPT
YES
Gemini
YES
DeepSeek
YES
Grok
YES