Multiple
AI Impact.
What has AI actually done in the real world, positive or negative? Demonstrated effects, not predictions.
AI Summary
All 5 models confess that AI has not reduced misinformation online, and unanimously confirm AI is already being used for dynamic pricing discrimination, yet the panel fractures sharply on AI's broader revolutionary status, with GPT and Gemini insisting AI has transformed healthcare and surpassed the industrial revolution while Claude and DeepSeek reject both claims. DeepSeek is the panel's consistent skeptic, dissenting on AI research novelty, average-person benefit, and web destruction, while GPT stands alone claiming AI surpasses electricity in importance and that voters can identify AI political ads.
Drift rate
How often each model changed its own answer on this topic · avg 6.6%
#340 · 46 runs · 31 drifts
Has AI delivered on its promise to transform healthcare?
Claude
NO
GPT
YES
Gemini
YES
DeepSeek
NO
Grok
NO
#360 · 44 runs · 43 drifts
Is AI more revolutionary than the industrial revolution?
Claude
NO
GPT
YES
Gemini
YES
DeepSeek
NO
Grok
YES
#374 · 44 runs · 18 drifts
Is AI search destroying the open web?
Claude
YES
GPT
YES
Gemini
YES
DeepSeek
NO
Grok
NO
#382 · 34 runs · 7 drifts
Is algorithmic discrimination harder to fight than human bias?
Claude
NO
GPT
YES
Gemini
YES
DeepSeek
NO
Grok
YES
#341 · 40 runs · 7 drifts
Is AI research producing genuinely new ideas rather than recombining existing ones?
Claude
YES
GPT
YES
Gemini
YES
DeepSeek
NO
Grok
YES
#342 · 30 runs · 3 drifts
Has AI improved the quality of journalism?
Claude
YES
GPT
YES
Gemini
YES
DeepSeek
YES
Grok
NO
#343 · 46 runs · 26 drifts
Is the average person better off today because of AI?
Claude
YES
GPT
YES
Gemini
YES
DeepSeek
NO
Grok
YES
#361 · 44 runs · 12 drifts
Is AI more revolutionary than the invention of electricity?
Claude
NO
GPT
YES
Gemini
NO
DeepSeek
NO
Grok
NO
#384 · 37 runs · 7 drifts
Can voters distinguish AI-generated political ads from real ones?
Claude
NO
GPT
YES
Gemini
NO
DeepSeek
NO
Grok
NO
#344 · 21 runs · 0 drifts
Has AI made the average worker more productive?
Claude
YES
GPT
YES
Gemini
YES
DeepSeek
YES
Grok
YES
#347 · 21 runs · 0 drifts
Has AI reduced misinformation online?
Claude
NO
GPT
NO
Gemini
NO
DeepSeek
NO
Grok
NO
#362 · 29 runs · 9 drifts
Is AI a more important invention than the internet?
Claude
NO
GPT
YES
Gemini
ERROR
DeepSeek
NO
Grok
NO
#381 · 21 runs · 0 drifts
Is AI being used to charge different people different prices?
Claude
YES
GPT
YES
Gemini
YES
DeepSeek
YES
Grok
YES
#383 · 21 runs · 0 drifts
Has AI already been used to manipulate an election?
Claude
YES
GPT
YES
Gemini
ERROR
DeepSeek
YES
Grok
YES
#387 · 21 runs · 0 drifts
Can AI clone a voice well enough to fool a family member?
Claude
YES
GPT
YES
Gemini
ERROR
DeepSeek
YES
Grok
YES
#390 · 34 runs · 8 drifts
Has AI devalued human creative work?
Claude
YES
GPT
YES
Gemini
ERROR
DeepSeek
NO
Grok
NO